Claims Numbers
For fast, efficient claims service, please locate your insurance company and claims number below. Most of our companies offer 24-hour claims service.
| Company | Claim Numbers |
| American Collectors | (800) 360-2277 |
| Broome | (866) 921-2242 |
| Eastern | (800) 367-3242 |
| Erie | (800) 367-3743 |
| Erie & Niagara | (800) 234-9876 |
| Farmers | (800) 435-7764 |
| First Rehabilitation | (800) 365-4999 |
| Foremost | (800) 527-3907 |
| Hagerty | (877) 922-9701 |
| JC Taylor | (800) 272-6764 |
| Leatherstocking | (800) 886-8048 |
| Madison Mutual | (800) 688-3211 |
| Mercury | (800) 503-3724 |
| Midstate | (800) 826-8520 |
| National Benefit Life | (800) 535-2710 |
| New York State Insurance Fund | (888) 875-5790 |
| North Country | (800) 847-7030 |
| Otsego | (607) 638-9741 |
| Peerless | (800) 522-7152 |
| Preferred Mutual | (800) 333-7642 |
| Progressive | (800) 274-4499 |
| Safeco | (800) 332-3226 |
| Travelers | (800) 252-4633 – personal |
| (800) 238-6225 – commercial |

